
Sid Mittra
Ph.D., Economics
Emeritus Professor, OU, Michigan
Part I
A Fairy Tale
The place was Rochester, Michigan. The day was Sunday, April 6, 1970. The time was 5:29 p.m. I was in my Oakland University office in North Foundation Hall, deeply engrossed in working on my next book, trying to prove that the university made the right decision in simultaneously granting me an early promotion to a full professorship, with life tenure. Suddenly the phone rang, shattering my concentration. I answered the phone, assuming that my wife, Bani, wanted to know what time I would come home for dinner.
“Hello, Professor Mittra. This is Bill, Associate Dean of the Music Department. How are you doing today?”
I responded in an angry tone: “Sir, you’ve got the wrong person. I am in the Economics Department and know nothing about music. Goodbye.”
“Sid, don’t hang up. I know who you are and I do want to talk to you. I want to make you an incredible offer that you could not possibly refuse. So, please hear me out.”
Then, without waiting for a response, Bill kept talking: “Itzhak Perlman — I hope you know this world renowned violinist — is coming to Oakland University as a special guest of our Music Department. He is going to stay here for eight weeks.”

Itzhak Perlman
Still anxious to end this meaningless conversation, I advised Bill that, although I was impressed by his success in getting Perlman to Oakland, I am not into music and would rather not carry on this conversion any further.
That’s when Bill threw me a curve ball. This is how he put it:
“Here is my offer. It is not generally known that Perlman is paralyzed from the waist down and is wheelchair bound. We would like him to stay in one of our university subdivision homes. I understand that you live in our subdivision at 721 McGill Drive. Your house has a double-door entrance, which is precisely what he needs for wheelchair access. So, if you let us rent your home from June 15 to August 15 and, during that time, take a long vacation with your family, we will make it worth your while to accept our offer.”

Our home had a specially built double door (not shown here)
After I caught my breath, I responded: “Bill, your offer is too good to be true. However, since my family is affected, I need to consult with my wife before making a final decision.”
Let me add here an important caveat. In 1970 when this conversation took place, I had never heard of Perlman. That is because at that time he was beginning to gain some reputation as a performer and he had started to accept invitations from various institutions to grow his reputation. But just to find out what kind of a musician Perlman had eventually turned out to be, I did a Google search in 2020 and discovered the following. And that made me feel very happy.
”Itzhak Perlman is an Israeli American violinist, conductor, and music teacher. Perlman has performed worldwide, in venues that have included a State Dinner at the White House honoring Queen Elizabeth II, and at the Presidential Inauguration of President Obama. He has conducted the Detroit Symphony Orchestra, the Philadelphia Orchestra, and the Westchester Philharmonic. In 2015, he was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom.”
That night I had an intense debate with Bani about Bill’s offer. She said that while she was always fully supportive of all my decisions, in this case she didn’t think she could deal with all that would be involved during an eight week period away from home, traveling all the time, no less. Still, in the end, based upon my seriously flawed sense of adventure, I was inclined to accept the offer.
The next day I did more checking, which revealed that we did not have a family member or friend who would be willing to accommodate our family for several weeks if we needed shelter on short notice. Even staying in inexpensive motels for two months would certainly be cost prohibitive for us. So, our only viable option appeared to be to drive around in our vehicle, carrying a portable tent, staying on camp grounds, and cooking dinner in the great outdoors. Our family had never done any of that, and the thought of pulling it off for such a long period scared the devil out of me.
The last issue we faced related to our transportation. We had a 1968 VW station wagon that was much smaller than American station wagons. I figured that if I carried our luggage and tent on a roof top carrier, then the VW’s cargo space would be sufficient for the kids (Rita, age 7, and Robert, age 4) to have a comfortable space for playing and sleeping.

In the end, I convinced myself that the chance of seeing America through this unique lens provided a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity that we could not afford to pass up. So, over Bani’s objections, I decided to accept the offer.
The next day I signed a contract with the university. Bill generously added a special clause to the contract providing that if I needed more money to pull it off, he would gladly oblige. With that assurance, we were on the verge of traveling around the country in a unique fashion.
Part II
Journey into the Unknown
- The first day
On June 12, we packed our bags, loaded them, along with dry food, large bags of chips and bottled water into the VW, and began our dream trip. I had AAA maps with me (there was no GPS in those days) to guide me. Even if I did get lost, I thought, so what? One thing we had plenty of, was time.
The first day turned out to be very eventful, but not in the way you might suspect. From Michigan we headed west through Illinois into Iowa before we stopped for the evening.
However, the drama that unfolded inside the car during that first day’s drive was truly novel. In those days, there were no laws against passengers riding in the cargo space without seat belts, so initially the kids had a ball playing monopoly (there were no iPads or cell phones in those days either), and having fun to their hearts’ content. However, after a few hours the novelty wore off and they started fighting with each other. Suddenly Rita screamed: “Mom, he is kicking me.” To that, Robert retorted: “She is exaggerating. I just touched her with my foot.” At that point, Bani reached back from the front seat, grabbed Robert and had him sit down on her lap. With no seat belts required and no rules against carrying a child on one’s lap on the front seat, Bani’s bold action created a new baby sitting technique that may have preserved our sanity.
Settling down for the evening provided another challenge. Although I had practiced putting up a tent at home, it proved to be a difficult job. After the tent was in place, I unloaded our luggage and helped Bani prepare dinner. While we were busy taking care of these chores, the kids had been enjoying the swings in a nearby playground and having a ball getting some much needed physical exercise. Once dinner was ready, we sat around a camp fire and enjoyed our meal under twinkling stars. The truth be known, everything we did felt awkward and could have been done better; but after a day of stressful driving, no one seemed to care. Through all of this, of course, Bani’s calm and reassuring demeanor played a significant role in making it a day to remember.
Finally, it was bedtime. The children were already fast asleep and Bani was still cleaning up after dinner. I lay down on my bed and said a thankful prayer: “Thank God, one day is over, and only 55 more days to go.”
- Rest of the trip
I would need many blogs to share in detail all the unique experiences we had on this trip. Our route took us across the northern tier of states, into Canada, to the west coast, down the west coast, across the southern U.S., and north along the east coast to Washington, D.C., before we headed back to Michigan. Our unique memories from this trip will last a lifetime.
Despite space constraints, however, I would be remiss if I did not invite you to visit my memory palace standing tall on four strong pillars. Two of these pillars represent scary experiences while the third one is amusing, and the fourth pillar is downright hilarious. So please join me as we visit my memory palace together.
Pillar One. Calgary, Canada. We had made reservations at a campsite in Calgary, which we had heard was unparalleled. When we arrived at the campsite, it looked like a sprawling big city with tents all over the place. The difference was that, unlike a city, there were no marked street signs and there were no street lights. That meant that if we got lost at night, there would be no way to find our tent until the next morning. The only good news was that we were allowed to park the VW next to our tent, as if that was of any help.
After arriving at the campsite and unloading the VW, we put up the tent and allowed the kids time to enjoy the playground, after which Bani cooked dinner in the open air oven. Everything went like clockwork. Around 10:00 p.m. we decided to call it a day. It was pitch dark outside and I reminded myself not to leave the tent at night for any reason.
It was around midnight when Bani woke me up to report that she heard a strange noise coming from outside the tent. Irritated, I told her that we had nothing anyone would want to steal so she should stop imagining things and go back to sleep. She woke me up again a few minutes later with the same observation. This time, I grudgingly picked up a flash light and carefully opened the tent door. I was shocked to see two glowing red eyes of a grizzly bear staring at me.

Luckily, my flashlight did the trick. The bear didn’t like it and slowly walked away. That did not placate Bani, who was so petrified by the incident that she insisted that we move to the VW for the rest of the night. This time I acquiesced. We made beds for the kids in the cargo space, and Bani and I prepared to sleep on the two reclining front seats. It was very uncomfortable, but at least we were safe, or so we thought.
As we were dozing off, the bear came back, and started pushing against the VW, trying to topple it. Not having any other options, while sweating profusely, I prayed to God for a miracle. Fortunately, after three failed attempts over an hour’s time, the bear decided to move on, presumably to annoy someone else.
God must have listened to my prayer.
Pillar Two. Las Vegas. This was our first visit to Las Vegas, so Bani and I decided to leave the kids with a babysitter in our hotel and spend the evening at a casino, enjoying a night of extravagance.
Bani had never gambled, so she was apprehensive about losing money. I suggested that she might not mind losing $25.00 (a significant amount for us in those days) and that she should gamble that amount to her heart’s content. In the meantime, I planned to go around the casino taking pictures and doing a little gambling. We agreed to meet in the lobby after two hours. I could sense that Bani was both excited and apprehensive about her pending gambling adventure.
I returned to the lobby as planned but could not find Bani. Not knowing where to look, I frantically searched for her at the gaming tables and surrounding areas, but had no luck finding her. Finally, in desperation, I asked an employee to help me locate her. When he heard that this was the first time Bani had been there to gamble, he suggested that I look for her in the slot machine section.

I was blown away when I saw her sitting in front of a slot machine, pulling the lever each time she put a dime in the slot. I noticed that she was down to 20 cents. She explained that when she was down to $1.00, she won a whole bunch of dimes, which kept her going; but now that she was down to 20 cents, she would soon be done.
Then something miraculous happened. She put in her last dime, pulled the lever, and whoosh! The slot machine began spewing out dimes in great numbers and didn’t stop until coins were falling onto the floor. A casino employee came forward, collected all the dimes, and weighed them. He then handed Bani $50.00 and congratulated her for winning big. She looked at me and said: “Waawee, I got my original money back and won an additional $25.00, which is exactly the amount we need to pay the babysitter. What an evening that turned out to be.
Pillar Three. Grand Canyon. Driving around the Grand Canyon was a thrilling and mesmerizing experience. It was early afternoon when we arrived, so we had plenty of time to enjoy that wonder of nature.

While driving around the canyon, I noticed a road descending down into the canyon. Thinking that it would be fun to have a closer look at the canyon, I entered that road. There were no signs (remember, it was 1970), but that did not concern me.
As the road descended, I noticed that the slope was very gentle, but there was no way to turn around. After a while I began to get anxious as we had travelled quite a distance and soon would be near the bottom; but since there was no choice I kept driving with trepidation.
As we neared the bottom, I felt the VW pulling suddenly to the right. I discovered that the right rear tire was leaking air. Oh my goodness, I thought, what did I get us into? My helpless family was in the car. I had no way to contact anyone (no cell phones in those days). It was getting dark, and soon I would have a flat tire making the car inoperable, and I still didn’t see a place to turn around. Oh God, is that how it is all going to end for my family? I took a deep breath and let it all out. Then I started driving slowly again, still going down toward the bottom of the canyon.
Suddenly, the miracle I had been silently praying for did occur. I saw a place to turn around. Encouraged, I pressed on the accelerator and started a fast climb, with the rear tire still leaking air. Luckily, in about 12 minutes, before I had a totally flat tire, I was able to get to the top of the canyon. Once there, I located a near-empty parking lot, parked the VW, and without saying a word to the family, placed my head on the steering wheel and passed out.
When I eventually woke up, I heard a cassette of the kids’ favorite music playing loudly. Bani had joined the kids in the cargo space and opened a big bag of Lay’s Doritos and three bottles of Coke. All three of them were laughing out loud and having a ball. Surprisingly, they showed no signs of distress and were behaving as though they were determined to enjoy the best possible party with Mom, even if Dad did not care to join them.

Pillar Four. Washington, D.C. Our final stop on this trip was in Washington, D.C., the nation’s capital. Since this was going to be our first family visit, I made a special effort to glorify this city by describing in some detail its major attractions, including the following, some of which I hoped we could visit: the Lincoln Memorial, the Washington Monument, the White House, the U. S. Capitol, the Thomas Jefferson Memorial, and the National Mall. I also pointed out that there are other unique attractions, such as Madame Tussauds wax museum, the Library of Congress and the Smithsonian’s National Zoo, home of the koala bears. I don’t know how much the kids absorbed from my enthusiastic lecture but, in the end, I sure felt talked out.
Fortunately, as soon as I finished talking, Bani took over. Realizing that the kids were getting somewhat bored with my monotonous speech, she attempted to perk them up by making them this unusual offer: “Since you kids have been really good during this entire trip, we will give you a special gift. You can decide which places you wish to visit. Remember, we are only going to be here for a little over half a day, so you need to choose carefully.”
What followed then was nothing short of an ear shattering response. Both kids screamed at the top of their voices: “The Zoo!”
My reaction to that was instantaneous. I slammed on the brakes, parked the VW on the side road and retorted: “I won’t allow you to skip all the great places I just described. I just won’t.”
Rita’s response to my denial was powerful: “Dad, you have taught us to always keep our promises. You promised that we could decide what places we wished to visit.”
“So I did,” I responded almost silently, as I realized that the score was settled for good.
The kids had the best day of their lives at the National Zoo. They visited the cubby holes of the lions, the tigers, the giraffes, the monkeys, the swans, the parrots, and a host of other animals we don’t normally see. But their biggest thrill was cuddling the koala bears that had recently been loaned to the Zoo by China. We realized that, at the end of the day, there was a lot more for the kids to see and enjoy, but we had no choice but to call it a day and head back to our motel.
The next morning as we were ready to leave, Robert pleaded in the most innocent voice: “Dad, I know you are going to say NO, but can we visit the koala bears one more time? I forgot to say goodbye to my favorite bear.”
That broke my heart.
Fortunately, this incident ended well. As soon as we returned home, I rushed to my study room and wrote the following note (I didn’t have a computer at that time) to be mailed the next day:
August 16, 1970
Director, Guinness World Records,
Please officially recognize the fact that the Mittra Family is the first family in the world that, on its first visit to Washington, D.C., did what no other
family has done – missed visiting any of the following of the nation’s capital’s famous attractions: the Lincoln Memorial, the Washington Monument, and the White House.
Not surprisingly,I am still waiting for the Guinness folks to publish our family’s story; but I am sure that they will eventually get around to it. After all, as the saying goes – it ain’t over ‘til it’s over.
Bottom Line
I’m sure you’d like to know my takeaway from this fairy tale. Bani and I had significantly different reactions. While I have extensively traveled around the country, I had never seen America through this unique lens. I saw scores of places I’d never otherwise have visited, met people from all over the world, witnessed the difference between traveling through Canada and the U.S., and accomplished all of this on someone else’s dime, without costing me a penny of my own money. In my judgment, this qualifies the adventure as a true fairy tale.
As for Bani, the most important thing she remembered was how it ended. After we returned home, she avoided seeing the kids, except for meal time, for a whole month. She swore that she could relive that experience any day, any time.
_________________________________________________________________________
Travis Smith provided technical support for this article. Charles Gauck professionally edited this blog and made valuable suggestions for improvement. Roger Wingelaar, formerly associated with Oakland Press, selected the title. However, the author takes full responsibility for the contents of this blog.
Feedback
If you’re enjoying what you’re reading, please consider recommending it the friends you like (and also to those you don’t like). They can sign up at sid.mittra1@gmail.com. If you want to share your thoughts on this or any other blog, or on my blogs in general, please email me at sid.mittra1@gmail.com.
















